The King spoke about the Queen’s lifelong service, and William, Camilla and Kate's new titles
This article has been updated to correct a source's job title.
During a recent rally in front of Newmarket’s municipal offices, Asian massage workers and their allies, including sex workers and migrant worker organizations, got together to send councillors and residents a clear message: we don’t need saving.
That’s in response to the town’s Bylaw-2020-31, which was purportedly passed to help eliminate the human trafficking and sex-work rings that local politicians and residents claim plague Asian massage parlours.
The bylaw, which went into effect in January, requires massage parlours without registered massage therapists – formerly known as body-rub parlours and currently called “alternative massage businesses” – to obtain a Personal Wellness Establishment (PWE) licence.
But to Asian workers like Mina Do (not her real name), a long-time organizer with Butterfly: Asian and Migrant Sex Worker Support Network, the bylaw is more of a “political agenda” being used strategically, particularly as a municipal election is coming up.
The result, she says, has been to either criminalize low-income Asian workers based on their immigration status; or victimize them based on a misplaced conflation of human trafficking and sex work associated with Asian massage parlours.
“You have to choose to either say you’re a victim (of human trafficking), otherwise you’re going to be deemed a criminal,” Do told NCM as she explained what happens during the police raids she says have been routinely targeting Asian massage parlours.
Do was speaking during the Aug. 28 rally, organized by Butterfly, which included demonstrators covering the building’s entrance with red flyers denouncing the bylaw.
Others held posters with messages like “Sex Work Is Work!”, “Rights, Not Rescue!” and “We Are Not Trafficked!”
“It’s classic xenophobia – people who just don’t understand this population and make a lot of false assumptions,” says Do.
In fact, in a statement to NCM, York Region Police say they have “not received any recent reports regarding human trafficking in body-rub establishments.”
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association and the Women’s Legal Education & Action Fund have also come out against the bylaw, calling it “discriminatory.”
Though she couldn’t be at the rally in person, NDP MPP for Toronto Centre Kristyn Wong-Tam also called for an end to “discriminatory policies” in a written message of solidarity that was read out loud:
“The PEW bylaw promotes anti-Asian racism…(and) disproportionately harms Asian massage workers. This is leading to Asian-owned massage businesses closing down, financial loss for Asian workers and their families,” the former Toronto councillor, originally from Hong Kong, wrote.
“I support the fight for fairness and join you in calling upon the local lawmakers to listen, respect and work with Butterfly and their allies to repeal the PWE bylaw and immediately end discriminatory policies.”
The Town of Newmarket did not respond to questions about the allegations or the rally.
Instead, a spokesperson sent a statement to NCM saying they’ve enacted the PEW licence bylaw “to do what is in our control as a municipality to license lawful businesses and give us the tools to shut down illegal activity in our community, which has been impacting neighbouring businesses and community members.”
Earlier this week the CCLA and LEAF sent a letter to Newmarket’s Council saying the bylaw has a “discriminatory impact by forcing primarily low-income Asian massage parlour workers – most of whom are women – out of work, violating their right to equality guaranteed under section 15 of the Charter.”
Butterfly is also circulating an open letter demanding, among other things, to “remove the absurd licensing bylaw that is clearly intended to drive us out of business.”
While the bylaw is ostensibly about bringing businesses up-to-code, in practice it has erected many barriers for low-income migrant workers.
For example, requiring certification from a Canadian institution, which is costly and offered only in English and French, is out of reach for most Asian massage workers, who are often low-income women with little-to-no English skills.
This doesn’t mean they are not qualified, says Elene Lam, Butterfly’s executive director, as many have years if not decades of on-the-job training both abroad and in Canada, or certification from their home country.
For instance, in an email statement, Lulu – who preferred to use a pseudonym out of fear of being harassed by authorities – says she opened her massage parlour in Newmarket more than a decade ago.
“Although it took three hours to drive back and forth from my house to the massage parlour,” she writes, she worked hard until she “gradually accumulated a good reputation.”
“Because of (the massage parlour), I have established a solid economic foundation that allows me to bring my family over and unite together. This industry allows me to balance between my family and work,” she writes.
Other similar testimonies can be found here: https://springmag.ca/asian-massage-parlour-workers-speak-out-against-discriminatory-bylaw
Under the new licensing regime, Lulu’s experience – which until now had been enough to legitimately be allowed to run a massage business – counts for nothing.
Since the bylaw was passed, all seven Asian massage parlours that applied for the licence before the April 2022 deadline have been denied, and at least two have been shut down. Those that have chosen to remain open are being fined $4,000-$5,000 daily, says Lam.
Lam says they know of four non-Asian parlours that were granted the licence, “but the (town of Newmarket) is reluctant to share” the type of training they have or criteria they met.
Vincent Wong is an assistant professor at Windsor University's faculty of law and was one of the speakers at the rally. He says that while it is “commonly known” that some establishments offer erotic massages and sex work – some Asian, some not – “it is definitely clear” that the bylaw is targeting Asian parlours and workers.
“What this essentially comes down to is a very arbitrary kind of legal decision-making that is, in effect, banning all Asian massage businesses,” he says.
Something similar is occurring in the prairies, where sex workers and body-rub parlour workers say the religious right and anti-sex work organizations are fighting to criminalize their profession.
The issue, Wong explains, is that there is a general tendency to conflate commercial sex work – which is legal in Canada – with human trafficking, which in turn is stereotypically associated with Asian massage parlours.
But there’s no evidence of that.
In fact, York Region Police (YRP) say “Most human trafficking in the region happens within hotels, condos and short-term rentals, not body-rub parlours.”
A recent report also found that there is general rise in anti-Asian racism and discrimination across Canada, including in the York Region, where Newmarket is located.
The report from the Chinese Canadian National Council Toronto Chapter – where Wong served as an adviser – found a disturbing upsurge of hate-crimes against the Asian community since the beginning of the COVID pandemic. Read the report here: https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/new-report-details-disturbing-rise-in-anti-asian-hate-crimes-in-canada-1.5358955
In the York Region specifically, police found that “the number of hate motivated crimes against East and Southeast Asian communities also grew 53 per cent in 2021,” as Global News reported earlier this year. See the article here: https://globalnews.ca/news/8782921/york-region-police-hate-crimes-increase-2021/
But the targeting of Asian massage parlours dates back to around 2012, says Wong, when “human trafficking started to become an all-encompassing policy orientation.”
While there isn’t sufficient data on Newmarket, data from Toronto – which Wong and the Chinese National Council Toronto Chapter collected through Freedom of Information requests – shows a clear bias against “holistic practitioners” of Asian descent.
That has included “excessive, unnecessary and discriminative inspections and prosecutions” of more than 2,200 practitioners, according to a summary of the data presented to the City of Toronto, “with individual bylaw visits conducted by as many as seven officers together, leading to neighbours and business disruption.” See the data here: https://www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2018/cc/comm/communicationfile-79714.pdf
“Since the majority of the holistic practitioners are racialized, particularly from Chinese and other Asian backgrounds, the excessive practices of law enforcement officers towards holistic centres and practitioners amounts to racial profiling and discrimination,” the summary states.
Back in Newmarket, Lam says a legal research team has formed in order to challenge the “illegal and unconstitutional policy and decision of the town.”
Until then, she adds, residents and councillors can expect more actions of resistance and solidarity.
Fernando Arce, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, New Canadian Media
Nova Scotia's finance minister appears lukewarm about the idea of raising the province's minimum wage at a higher rate and faster pace than already planned, despite the increasing pressures caused by inflation. Speaking to reporters in Halifax following a cabinet meeting Thursday, Allan MacMaster acknowledged that people making minimum wage are facing a particular struggle, but he said their employers are as well. "And I think we, as a government, have to be careful as well about creating uncert
WASHINGTON (AP) — In Orange County, California, where the typical house sells for $1 million, Rep. Katie Porter’s four-bedroom, three-bath residence in a leafy subdivision on the University of California Irvine campus is a bargain. The progressive Democrat and law professor, who has lamented the cost of housing in her district, purchased it in 2011 for $523,000, a below-market price secured through a program the university uses to lure academics who couldn’t otherwise afford to live in the afflu
News bulletin 2022/09/08 22:16View on euronews
Between 1951 and 2010, the British monarch visited Canada on 23 official tours.
A timeline of how the search and eventual arrest of accused killer Myles Sanderson unfolded.
Catch up with the most important stories from around Europe and beyond - latest news, breaking news, World, Business, Entertainment, Politics, Culture, Travel.View on euronews
The cost of gas is up slightly in the weekly fuel price update from the Public Utilities Board, rising by just more than half a cent per litre. Diesel, furnace oil and stove oil prices are all down by about $0.03 a litre. Propane is up, however, by just over one cent per litre. The current cost of regular, unleaded gas on the Avalon Peninsula is just more than $1.67 a litre and hovering around $1.70 for much of the island. Prices in Labrador range from $1.73 in Labrador West to $2.32 in Cartwrig
In his first address to the nation and the Commonwealth, King Charles pays tribute to his 'darling mama' and pledges to serve with 'loyalty, respect and love.'
Two people have been charged in connection with the death of a Toronto woman at a Newmarket home in late July. York Regional Police say a 23-year-old man has been charged with second-degree murder, possession of a firearm and possession of a prohibited weapon in the death of Nicole Mercer. An 18-year-old woman has been charged with accessory after the fact to murder, possession of a firearm and possession of a prohibited weapon. Both of those charged are from Newmarket, police say. Police say th
British officials will gather at St. James's Palace on Saturday to formally proclaim King Charles III as the new monarch. Charles automatically became the King when his mother, Queen Elizabeth, died on Thursday at the age of 96. But the pending Accession Council is the next formal step in the 73-year-old Charles's nascent journey as sovereign — just as it was for his late mother; his grandfather, King George VI; and also for Queen Victoria. Unlike those prior occasions, this one will be televise
Londoners shared get-well wishes for Queen Elizabeth after doctors expressed concern about the health of the 96-year-old monarch. The Queen remains at Balmoral Castle under medical supervision.
The man arrested following attacks earlier this week in the Homesteader neighbourhood has been charged by Edmonton police. Clarence Lawrence, 25, is facing a second-degree murder charge and two counts of aggravated assault, according to a police news release issued Friday. Around 2:30 p.m. Wednesday, police received numerous calls that three people had been stabbed in the area of Hermitage Road and Henry Avenue. Officers found the body of one man as well as two injured women, aged 32 and 41, who
OTTAWA — The death of the Queen has prompted the Conservative Party of Canada to rethink how it plans to announce it next leader. The party had been planning to do so with an event in Ottawa on Saturday, but the death of the monarch now means the country will be in a period of mourning during that time. The chair of the party's leadership election organizing committee says in a statement the party will respect the protocols surrounding her death. Ian Brodie says the committee "is considering an
Elon Musk files amended counterclaims vs Twitter under seal
Plans to create 430 rental units at the site of Tartan Downs, a former harness racing track in Sydney, N.S., are stalled due to a lack of funding, says its promoters. Cape Breton University (CBU) and the non-profit group Urban Neighbourhood Development Association says the project would address a housing shortage in the community. It has so far received $100,000 from Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC). But backers say work can't go forward without more money from the Crown corporat
At a news conference on Wednesday, Saskatchewan RCMP Commanding Officer Rhonda Blackmore described her hopes for the James Smith Cree Nation after her visit to the community earlier that day. “I hope that this brings them some sense of closure in that they can rest easy tonight, knowing that Myles Sanderson is no longer a threat to them,” Blackmore said. “Hopefully this is the first step to allow them to start that healing process, that grieving process.”
LONDON (Reuters) -Banks including Deutsche Bank and BofA said on Friday they expect another 75 basis point rate hike from the European Central Bank in October, a day after the central bank delivered a supersized interest-rate rise of that size to tame inflation. The ECB raised its key rates by an unprecedented 75 basis points (bps) on Thursday and promised further hikes, prioritizing the fight against inflation even as the bloc is likely heading towards a winter recession and gas rationing. "It is likely to be another close call in October and we have shifted our view to expect another 75 bps hike," Deutsche Bank analysts said in a note, from its previous call of 50 bps.
Queen Elizabeth, Canada's head of state and the longest-reigning British monarch, has died. She was 96. She died peacefully on Thursday afternoon at Balmoral Castle in Scotland, Buckingham Palace said in a short statement. "The King and The Queen Consort will remain at Balmoral this evening and will return to London tomorrow," the palace said, in reference to the Queen's son Charles, who automatically became king upon her death, and his wife, Camilla. In a separate statement, King Charles called
NICE, France (AP) — The start of a match between Nice and Cologne in the Europa Conference League on Thursday was delayed because of fights among supporters in the stands at Allianz Riviera stadium. UEFA said the kickoff was pushed back by 55 minutes to 7.40 p.m. local time because of crowd disturbances. TV footage showed fans fighting before the start of the match at the Nice stadium. ___ More AP soccer: https://apnews.com/hub/Soccer and https://twitter.com/AP_Sports The Associated Press
Most Canadians have never known a world in which Queen Elizabeth II wasn't their official head of state. News of the longest-serving British monarch's death sent shock waves of grief across Canada on Thursday. From political leaders, to royal officers, to everyday citizens, Canadians remembered the sovereign as a paragon of duty and enduring part of the national fabric. "I think she'll be remembered as one of the country's greatest icons," said Robert Finch, chairman of the Monarchist League of